Blog
Hiring for skills: requirements, work samples and selection
How companies replace formal degree requirements with concrete competencies: a comparison of key figures, seven implementation steps, examples of work samples and answers to common objections.
Reviewing formal degrees as a selection criterion
A university degree was long a common entry requirement. Companies should examine more closely which of the skills needed for the work a degree actually demonstrates. The link between educational credentials and job performance is weaker than is often assumed.
Arguments for reviewing degree requirements
Correlation with later job performance
Degrees have a 16% correlation with professional success, skills assessments 74%. This speaks for testing actual skills more directly.
Barriers to entry
In the USA, degree requirements exclude 52% of the workforce. Minorities and people on low incomes are particularly affected.
How current the knowledge is
Technology often develops faster than curricula. A 4-year software development degree may therefore include tools or frameworks that are already outdated.
Costs without corresponding differences in performance
Degree requirements lead to salaries that are 20–30% higher without a corresponding rise in productivity.
What skills-based selection involves
Removing degree requirements is only one step. Requirements, selection processes and career development all have to relate to demonstrable skills.
Describe competencies in concrete terms
Define measurable skills for each role. Example: ‘Python skills and experience in optimising database queries’ instead of ‘computer science degree’.
The requirement should be concrete, verifiable and relevant to the role.
Assess skills in practice
Work samples, simulations and technical tasks show what someone can actually do. They complement assessment based on degrees and interviews.
Assess the skills that are decisive for the work, not just knowledge that is easy to test.
Widen the pool of candidates
Also consider graduates of intensive practical courses (bootcamps), self-taught professionals, career changers and others with non-traditional educational backgrounds.
Suitable skills can be acquired in different ways.
Enable internal development
Internal programmes can support employees in building new competencies. Demonstrated skills thus become the basis for moving into other roles.
Development opportunities are based on ability and learning progress.
Comparison of key figures
Degree-based and skills-based selection lead to the following results.
| Metric | Selection by degree | Selection by skills | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to hire | 42 days | 28 days | 33% faster |
| Quality of hire | 3.2/5.0 | 4.1/5.0 | 28% higher |
| Retention after 12 months | 73% | 87% | 19% improvement |
| Share of under-represented groups | 18% | 31% | 72% increase |
| Cost per hire | US$4,800 | US$3,100 | 35% lower |
Example: IBM
After IBM dropped the degree requirement for more than 50% of its US roles, the performance of employees selected on the basis of skills was equally good or better in 94% of roles. After 2 years, 87% of them were still with the company, compared with 72%.
Seven steps to skills-based selection
Review existing requirements
Go through every job description. For each degree requirement, ask which specific knowledge or skills it is meant to demonstrate. Often these have not yet been described precisely.
Tasks for the audit:
- Record the roles with formal degree requirements.
- Document the skills and knowledge actually needed.
- Distinguish qualifications that are legally or professionally necessary, for example in medicine and the legal professions, from interchangeable selection criteria.
Create a competency profile
Together with managers and experienced employees, identify 5–8 skills that are decisive for success in the role.
Example: software development:
Develop and optimise algorithms.
Write clear code and good documentation.
Find and fix errors systematically.
Collaborate across departments.
Learn and apply new technologies.
Understand how the system architecture fits together.
Develop suitable work samples
Create role-related tasks, simulations or practical exercises that reflect the actual demands of the work.
Possible forms of assessment:
- Assess technical knowledge: coding tasks, design tasks and case studies.
- Assess thinking and problem-solving: problem-solving simulations and analytical tasks.
- Assess behaviour in work situations: situational judgement tests and role plays.
- Portfolio: review earlier work, projects and the candidate's own contributions.
Make job descriptions concrete
Replace interchangeable educational requirements with verifiable competencies and expected tasks.
Previous wording, example:
‘Bachelor's degree in marketing required. More than 5 years of experience in digital marketing.’
Concrete alternative:
‘Demonstrable experience in building and optimising search engine campaigns with budgets of over US$100,000. Please use your portfolio to show how you improved the financial return.’
Prepare the hiring team
Recruiters and managers need shared standards for assessing competencies, conducting structured interviews and dealing with unconscious bias.
Training content:
- Recognise transferable skills from different educational and career paths.
- Run and score skills assessments consistently.
- Apply structured interview techniques.
- Recognise a one-sided weighting of formal degrees in the assessment.
Open up further sourcing channels
Supplement traditional university recruiting with partnerships with training providers, learning platforms and regional programmes.
Possible candidate sources:
Coding bootcamps such as General Assembly and Flatiron.
Learning platforms such as Coursera and Udacity.
Portfolios and contributions on GitHub and Stack Overflow.
Apprenticeship programmes.
Programmes for the transition from military to civilian employment.
Community colleges and vocational schools.
Measure results and improve the process
Review the suitability of the people hired, their retention, their performance and the diversity of the team. Revise competency models and tasks on the basis of the results.
Suitable metrics:
- Performance reviews after 90 days, compared by selection method.
- Retention after 12 months, broken down by selection method.
- Changes in diversity in the applicant pool and among hires.
- Time until new employees work productively on their own.
- Correlation between assessment result and later job performance.
Common objections and answers
Objection: degrees show intelligence and work discipline.
Answer: degrees also depend on access to education and financial means. Practical skills assessments can capture the quality of work more directly. Companies record equally good or better cognitive test results after making the change.
Objection: skills assessments take too much time.
Answer: a 60-minute task can replace 3–4 interview rounds and shorten time to hire by 33%. AI-supported platforms help with evaluation even for thousands of applicants.
Objection: clients expect employees with a university degree.
Answer: explain the quality of the selection process and the results achieved. A transparent skills assessment can build trust and at the same time take further groups of candidates into account.
Objection: degrees are necessary for certain roles.
Answer: regulated professions, such as medicine, law or certain engineering activities, differ from many other roles in a company. Whether a formal qualification is required must be checked for the activity and the country; a degree must not be dropped across the board.
Developing skills-based selection further
More companies will publish their results, and technical tools are speeding up the assessment of skills. As a result, evidence of competencies can continue to gain importance in candidate selection.
Start with suitable roles and measurable criteria. Check regularly whether the process supports better hiring decisions.
Evaluating skills with Talenty
Talenty uses AI to evaluate work samples, simulations and portfolios. The resulting competency ratings support the assessment of actual skills and make selection less dependent on formal degrees.
You can ask the team for a demo and for the guide to skills assessment.
More articles
AI-generated and human-written interview questions compared
How AI derives interview questions from job requirements and competencies, checks questions for possible bias and evaluates answers. With sample questions for different roles.
ReadHow the application process influences the choice of employer
From the job search to the first day at work: how clear processes, reliable feedback and well-prepared interviews support applicants in their decision.
ReadCalculating the costs and benefits of recruitment automation
A model for the business case: software costs, working time saved, shorter time to fill and further benefit assumptions, with formulas and worked examples.
ReadSee Talenty with your jobs?
30 minutes, with an example from your recruiting.