Blog

How the application process influences the choice of employer

From the job search to the first day at work: how clear processes, reliable feedback and well-prepared interviews support applicants in their decision.

The application process shapes your employer brand

83% of candidates could change their mind about a company they previously valued after a negative interview experience. Companies with particularly good candidate experiences achieve a 70% higher offer acceptance rate and three times as many employee referrals. In 2025 the quality of the application process is therefore a key factor in the competition for staff.

Why candidate experience is becoming more important

With the spread of remote work, candidates can work for companies anywhere in the world. Competition for suitable employees is increasing as a result. Applicants remember how they were treated during the selection process.

Reviews on Glassdoor and other platforms

72% of candidates share negative experiences on review platforms. One bad experience can therefore put hundreds of other interested people off applying.

Example:

‘I put 6 hours into a take-home assignment and never heard back. Would not recommend to anyone.’ – 847 helpful votes

Positive experiences lead to recommendations

Candidates with positive experiences are 38% more likely to accept an offer and three times more likely to recommend the company – even if they are not hired themselves.

Example:

‘I did not get the job, but the process was very good. I applied for 3 more positions and recommended the company to 2 friends.’ – a common outcome

Impact on the business

Companies in the top quartile for candidate experience generate 50% more revenue per employee. New employees there reach full productivity twice as fast.

Applicants can also be customers

58% of candidates would buy less often from the company concerned after a bad application experience. How applicants are treated can therefore also affect customer acquisition.

The 5 stages of a good application process

The candidate experience is formed at every point of contact: from the first impression through the selection decision to the time afterwards. These contacts fall into the following stages.

First impression: provide information about the job

Candidates find out about your company even before applying. The careers page, job description and public presence shape their expectations.

What matters:

  • An informative careers page with employee stories and videos of everyday working life
  • Clear job descriptions that name tasks and outcomes specifically
  • Transparent salary ranges and benefits
  • A clear application path that also works well on mobile
  • Realistic insights into the work so that candidates can judge the fit for themselves

Practical tip:

Show a video of a typical working day for every role. Candidates who watch such videos accept offers 45% more often because expectations are aligned early on.

Application: limit the effort

60% of candidates abandon applications because they are too long or too complicated. Every additional input field can cause more suitable applicants to drop out.

What makes applications harder:

  • Having to upload a CV and then enter the same details again by hand
  • Asking for references right at the start
  • Multi-page forms with more than 20 fields
  • No option to save and continue later
  • No indication of how long it is likely to take

Recommendations for the application path:

  • One-click application, importing LinkedIn data or details from the CV
  • Can be completed in 5 minutes at most
  • Ask only for the information needed at first
  • Easy to use on mobile devices
  • Immediate confirmation of receipt with the next steps

Key figure:

Companies that cut the application time from 15 to 5 minutes raised the share of completed applications from 42% to 89%.

Screening: keep candidates informed

Submitting an application and then hearing nothing is the most common complaint about recruiting. 94% of candidates want feedback on their interview; only 41% receive it.

Communication throughout the process:

  • 1. Confirm receipt
  • Immediately after the application
  • Confirmation of receipt by email with the expected timeline
  • 2. Give feedback on screening
  • Within 48 hours
  • Initial feedback on screening – even if you need more time at first
  • 3. Prepare for the next stage
  • Before every further stage
  • Information for preparation: interviewers, schedule and notes on the appointment
  • 4. Communicate the outcome and next steps
  • After the interview

Personal feedback whether the answer is yes or no, concrete next steps and the date of the decision

Note on automation:

AI-supported communication tools can send personal status updates automatically. Talenty combines individual wording with reliable feedback to all candidates.

Interview: hold a well-prepared conversation

Interviews are an opportunity to show what working together is like, to assess suitability and to build interest in the job. At the same time, 58% of candidates report conversations that they experienced as an interrogation or a waste of time.

What makes a good interview:

Keep to time

Start on time and keep to the agreed length. Tell candidates immediately if an appointment is running late.

Come prepared

Read the CV beforehand. A general prompt such as ‘Tell me about yourself’ comes across as unprepared if the application has clearly not been read.

Allow questions in both directions

Set aside at least 15 minutes for the candidate’s questions. They show what matters to the person and what interests them.

Show what working together is really like

Share real experiences, arrange conversations with future colleagues and offer a tour on site or online.

Coordinate the interview rounds

Each interviewer assesses specific competencies. Avoid the same general opening question in every round.

State the next steps

End the conversation with a clear timeframe, for example: ‘You will hear from us about the next steps by Friday.’

Offer and start date: stay in touch

19% of candidates have withdrawn from offers they had already accepted. The often neglected period between acceptance and the first day at work is therefore particularly important.

From the job offer to the first day:

  • Deliver the offer personally: call first, then send the written offer and respond to the individual.
  • Stay in touch before the start date: send a welcome pack, invite the person to team events, name a contact for onboarding and share a plan for the first week.
  • Simplify the admin: provide documents digitally, explain the steps clearly and prepare IT access before the first day.
  • Prepare the first day: set up the workplace, configure the laptop, organise a welcome from the team and plan lunch together.

Case example:

Shopify sends new employees a package with a laptop, branded merchandise and a personal note from their manager 1 week before they start. The withdrawal rate is 0.3%, compared with an industry average of 17%.

Checking candidate experience with metrics

Track the following metrics to assess the experience of applicants and the effect of changes to the process.

MetricWhat it measuresTarget
Candidate NPS (net promoter score)Would candidates recommend your application process?40+; particularly good: 60+
Application completion rateShare of applications started that are submitted85%+
Offer acceptance rateShare of offers that are accepted85–90%
Response timeAverage time to feedback at each stageUnder 48 hours
Interview attendance rateShare of scheduled interviews that candidates attend90%+
Glassdoor ratingPublic rating of the interview experienceAt least 4.0 stars

Improvements you can make at short notice

You do not have to redesign the whole process first. The following changes can be made in less than 1 week and improve how the application process is perceived.

Automated status updates

Set up emails for key steps: application received, application under review and decision made.

Information before the interview

Create a short PDF with the schedule, the interviewers and tips for preparation. Send it 24 hours before the conversation.

Ask for feedback on the process after the interview

After the interview, send a survey with 3 questions, for example: ‘How did you find the process?’ and ‘What can we improve?’

Rejections with helpful feedback

Add 1–2 sentences of helpful feedback to a rejection instead of only stating in general terms that the process will not continue.

Simplify the application form

Remove input fields for details that are not needed at first. Aim for a completion time of 5 minutes and test the form on mobile devices.

Stay in touch for future vacancies

Invite rejected candidates to join a talent pool for future vacancies. 40% of them accept the invitation.

Supporting communication with applicants through AI

Talenty.ai automates recurring tasks in communication with applicants. These include timely status updates and personal feedback, even with large numbers of applicants.

Next steps: watch the platform demo and download the candidate experience audit template.

About the author

Jennifer RodriguezHead of Candidate Experience at Talenty.ai

Jennifer has been analysing and improving application processes for 12 years, including at Airbnb, HubSpot and Salesforce. She is the author of ‘The Candidate Experience Playbook’ and has helped more than 500 companies strengthen their hiring through better processes for applicants.

See Talenty with your jobs?

30 minutes, with an example from your recruiting.

Book a demo